Writing menu

Scripts

Reviews
    Film
    Games
    Music

Short stories

Game design pitches

Film Reviews

BEAUTIFUL INCONGRUITY
Metropolis dir. Rintaro | written by Katsuhiro Otomo
Official site| IMDB


This is a strange duck, a film by the legendary anime director Rintaro based upon a manga by another legend Osamu ("Kimba the White Lion", "Astroboy") Tezuka, which was based upon his impression of the poster of the Fritz Lang film: 'Metropolis'. I'm not going to make fun of this idea because, like all examples of extreme inspiration, it has its elements of brilliance. In this case, I found it all a bit unaffecting. There is no denying that the conjunction of Rintaro ("Galaxy Express 999") and Katsuhiro Otomo ("Ghost in the Shell", "Akira") has provided a film of startling imagery and a newness of design that is challenging. However, for non-anime fans the clash of graphic elements of Rintaro's cutesy characters (think "Astroboy") layered on top of art deco and industrial backgrounds may be daunting. Furthermore, the admittedly brave injection of jazz and blues music (in the climax of the film, a huge explosion, the soundtrack breaks out into "I can't help loving you") as the soundtrack can be weird and inappropriate. I also found the nods in some of the shots to classic American film jarring such as various odes to the Godfather and de Palma. I was told that the bad subtitles in the first third of the film were 'stylistic' by my anime fan friends but, well, there's no excuse for lack of readability. And while non-anime fans might find the plot to be interesting, I found the plot fairly standard: the corrupt government funding a huge project that will be brought down by rebels who try to protect a special being with the power to destroy or save society. Sound familiar? Sound like Akira?

In theatres now

 
 

back to the top

 


copyright© 2002 Keith Loh

 


Click here to get back to the Keith Loh main page