Writing menu

Scripts

Reviews
    Film
    Games
    Music

Short stories

Game design pitches

Film Reviews

THE LORD OF ALL FANTASIES
THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE FELLOWSHIP OF THE RING
IMDB | Official Site
dir. Peter Jackson
A fantastically realised picture. The finest escapist film yet.


Incredibly rich realisation.



It seems almost redundant now to add my voice to the army of glowing reviews that have heralded "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" as the best film of the year. By now, there are hundreds of reviews relating how much of a miracle this production is, how risky the investment was, and what genius it spawned. Many reviewers start out by telling the reader how it has been ages since they read the entire book, or how they never were bothered to finish it, start it, or even consider opening it. The reviews then take on the arduous task of summarizing the story, which in lesser movies, would have taken a line or a paragraph. It's certainly a statement on the depth of this film that it usually takes reviewers three or four paragraphs to do the same.

I won't do any of that. Let's cut to the chase.

This is an incomparable movie. A grand, epic fantasy of this like has never been attempted, much less carried out with such frevor, such energy, and commitment to vision. A production that rings true on almost all counts from production design, to casting, to music, special effects, and to the sure hand of the genius Peter Jackson. You would have to delve back into the films of Ray Harryhausen or Biblical epics to find any comparison in scale and tone. "Conan the Barbarian" and "Excalibur" were the last films, made almost decades ago, that even attempted to connect with the audience with such an uncompromising vision.

All hail Peter Jackson. He had amused us with his quirky, yet entertaining horror fare in "Dead Alive" (also known as "Brain Dead"), gave us glimpses of his character in "Heavenly Creatures" and "The Frighteners", and has been huddled away in New Zealand, the land of Middle Earth, for more than two and a half years, toiling away at what is a work of unbridled joy.

It is the love he shows for the content that wreathes this entire film with a glow, a giddy aura that will seldom not connect with the audience. The production design of Grant Major and the army of designers at Weta is peerless and seems a shoo-in for awards. The grand scenery of New Zealand, a real star of this film, is masterfully used to stand in for the larger-than-life vistas of Middle Earth. The adventurers are often filmed in a lilluputian scale next to epic mountains, brilliantly green rolling hills, or in a watery chasm, evoking the scale seen in Bruce Beresford's "Black Robe" or David Lean's "Lawrence of Arabia". The cast of the film, almost uniformly, is excellent, from the moral yet mischievous presence of Gandalf, played by Sir Ian McKellen, to the brooding sexiness of the Viggo Mortensen's human ranger Aragorn, and to the frightened yet brave hobbit Frodo, played by former child star Elijah Wood. The supporting cast is perfect, as well, with particular verve displayed by Sean Bean as the troubled warrior Boromir, the menacing Christopher Lee as the turncoat wizard Saruman and Goonies' star Sean Astin as loyal Hobbit Sam McGee.

All hail Weta, the FX studio set up by Jackson in New Zealand that began producing effects almost unnoticed years ago for films such as Jackson's "Frighteners", "Contact" and then took on the heroic task of creating the underlying special effects for this masterwork. These were effects that were not overblown, but were skillfully weaved into the tapestry by the designers and Jackson. Several images spawning from the collaboration of camera trickery, digital effects, and set design will resonate in the audience's memory long after the film has ended. These include a magical Elf city of trellises, gazebos and glowing pillars; the dark, underground city of Moria with a fantastic set piece of a broken stone bridge hanging out over a chasm; the hell burnt transformation of the magical tower of Isengard from a shining needle in a pristine forest into the blackened workshop of the forces of darkness; and the cheery green Hobbiton which is the starting point of the quest.

The flaws in this movie are more than outweighed by its greatness. From time to time, the mostly excellent heroic score by longtime Cronenberg collaborator Howard Shore intrudes into what should be quiet scenes. The battle scenes are too hectic and suffer from the dizzy-cam approach. The design of the Uruk-hai baddies doesn't measure up to that of the other monsters: the cave troll, the magnificently terrible Balrog, the shrieking Ringwraiths and even the ubiquitous Orcs. The digital formations in the flashback of the ancient battle against Sauron seemed to regular, a fault more expressly shown in much lesser films such as "The Mummy Returns" and "The Patriot". The film also tends to drag in parts of the first third before the true 'fellowship' group is formed, which is more to do with the source material than the script.

Yet, these flaws are as nothing compared to what Jackson and his filmmakers have striven for, which is to bring the spirit and scape of J.R.R. Tolkein's imagination onto the screen. There is hardly any part of the movie that does not speak of the love the filmakers have for the story and aspirations of "The Lord of the Rings" novels . The film does not slavishly follow the book's more obscure passages, yet doesn't pander to modern tastes of the audience. It's a take it or leave it approach that more films could benefit by, sticking to its vision and offering the audience the opportunity, for three delirious hours, to sink into a dream.

It must be said again. An incomparable movie.

In theatres now

 
 

back to the top

 


copyright© 2002 Keith Loh

 


Click here to get back to the Keith Loh main page