It's always interesting to see
what Hollywood insiders consider their gems of the
year so of course I had to pay attention to the 2005
Academy nomations. You can read them
here
and now read my comments.
Overall, a strong showing from indie and small films
this year. While I don't feel very strongly over any
one of these films, it's nice to know that the quality
of stories and performances can sometimes win the
hearts of cynical Academy members over big budget
costume glitz - the regular Oscar teases or larger
than life biopics.
"Brokeback Mountain" is definitely worth
seeing. Its strength is in a core of very heartfelt
scenes that are tied together in a very laconic fashion.
That and two excellent performances by
Heath
Ledger and
Michelle
Williams (really, everyone in that movie is
good). I think it has received so much acclaim this
year because it is a touchstone film. Similarly, "In
the Heat of the Night" was a touchstone film
for race relations.
"I watched "Crash" last night and
was underwhelmed. A handful of good performances
knitted together in a series of superficial preachy
stories. Happenstance I can handle, even an urban
fairytale. I hesitate to besmirch a Canadian screenwriting
success story in producer-director-writer Paul
Haggis but I felt that he could have made
a stronger film with fewer storylines instead of
skipping around to seemingly cover every single
racial division in L.A. I may be in the minority
because I also wasn't taken by last year's eventual
Oscar winner: "Million Dollar Baby" which
Haggis wrote.
I'm sad that "Syriana" was left off but
I can figure it was because it was a movie about
how the major characters are actually minor characters
and the conflict is almost unknowable. Also, the
voters probably thought they had seen the same thing
before and it was called "Traffic".
I have a sense that if Ang
Lee wins for Best Director it will be because
the Academy feels guilty for giving the Oscar to
Steven Soderbergh the year Lee should have won for
"Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon". This
is not to say that his direction in "Brokeback"
isn't good, it is, just not the overt stylish direction
that begs for recognition. For that, I expected
David Cronenberg
to receive a nod for "History of Violence".
His ommision on a list that still includes the obligatory
Steven Spielberg nomination is the most glaring
(at least there was a "History" nod for
Adapted Screenplay). I was glad to see Bennet Miller
get his first nod for "Capote". He really
had a difficult job with "Capote".
The nomination for best actor is between Philip
Seymour Hoffman and Ledger. Hoffman is filling
a bigger than life character while Ledger is more
down to earth. If I was a cynical Academy watcher
I would say that Hoffman would get it because he
is playing such a strange character and has worked
so hard to fill the real Capote's shoes. An Academy
voter might also conclude that Ledger has a great
future ahead of him and will end up being nominated
agai while Hoffman - who has been a supporting actor
mostly - may never get another opportunity to be
Best Actor. But myself, I know no performance from
film that shook me more than the scene where Ledger's
Ennis is so destroyed by saying goodbye to his lover
at the end of the summer that he collapses in an
alley and only can beat the wall in frustration
and self-hatred and loss. I regret I haven't seen
"Good Night and Good Luck" so I can't
rate David Strathairn
for best actor.
I unfortunately only saw one performance in the
Best Actress category. All I can say is that Kiera
Knightely belongs among the nominations. "Pride
and Prejudice" with better marketing and in
any other year woud have been up there. It was a
beautiful, lively film.
I'm happy that William
Hurt received recognition for his supporting
role in "History of Violence". He was
so quirky and awesome. Amy
Adams was really wonderful in "Junebug".
Actually I would recommend everyone rent that this
weekend. A really funny, weird movie. Did anyone
know she was an English actor? Catharine
Keener was the only heart in "Capote"
- and she was good - but I didn't feel her character
had a major part to play in that film. She had a
better role in "The 30 Year Old Virgin"
which would end up on my best of list this year.
The only category for which I've seen all the nominated
films was for Adapted Screenplay. Although I assume
one criteria for being nominated in that is in the
strength of screenplay, I think when it comes down
to it, the vote goes to the best screenplay period.
Of the five "Munich" is the most driven
but not entirely effective (see January for my review).
All four others had very interesting and challenging
issues. "The Constant Gardner" (Jeffrey
Caine) swam back and forth between flashbacks.
"Capote" struggled to find conflict within
the byplay between a killer and a predatory writer.
"Brokeback Mountain" was sparse and used
space as a sop for the audience's emotional filling-in.
These aren't criticisms but points of interest to
me. That leaves, to me, Josh
Olsen's "A History of Violence".
I've read that a lot of it was Cronenberg's adaptation
but it doesn't matter. On the screen, "A History
of Violence" challenged me with its change
of tone, its building but then sudden shifts in
tone and in its edge on look at the two sides of
human nature.
Of the original screenplay category I've only seen
"Syriana" and "Crash", neither
of which I think is that memorable.
The noms for cinematography I can't comment on having
seen only "The New World" and "Brokeback
Mountain". Of those two, "The New World"'s
lenser Emmanuel Lubezki had the most work to do.
I'm a bit surprised not to see "Munich"'s
Janusz Kaminski not recognized for his 70s gritty
thriller style. But then he has been to the podium
before.
"Paradise Now" in the best foreign picture
category is a very special movie and will rate higher
than most movies on my best of 2005 list. It is
a much better movie than "Munich" which
skirts the same subject matter. Why is "2046"
not anywhere on the noms? The answer is simple.
It was released very poorly and the Wong
Kar Wei did himself no service by coming
to festivals with an unfinished product. That said,
I wish it was at least recognized somewhere.